Vacation is all about treating yourself to the good things in life. While staying at our gorgeous St. Augustine condos, that means enjoying some of the best cuisine in town, including pizza. Whether you prefer thin-crust pies, calzones, or a traditional Italian slice, the restaurants offering the best pizza in St. Augustine have it all.
Explore the St. Augustine pizza scene at any one of the great local restaurants listed below. Plus, because they’re close to our St. Augustine condo rentals, you won’t have to go far to indulge in a slice or two.
Tony’s Pizza
Craving a taste of authentic New York Style pizza? Look no further than Tony’s Pizza right near Beacher’s Lodge! With over 31 years of experience, Tony’s Pizza delights customers in the Crescent Beach and Saint Augustine area. What sets Tony’s Pizza apart is their commitment to using only the freshest, high-quality ingredients in their made-from-scratch meals. From mouthwatering pizzas, pastas, and calzones to delicious subs and salads, every dish is crafted with care using old family recipes. Plus, their extra large pies for pizza by the slice are made fresh every hour. Don’t miss out on the local favorites like the Hawaiian Pizza, Meat Lovers, and The Greek, each packed with unique flavors that will leave you craving for more. Your taste buds will thank you!
Carmelo’s Marketplace
Located on the southwest end of the historic district, Carmelo’s Marketplace is the perfect place to grab lunch while spending the day exploring. Full of charming character, Carmelo’s has been in business for nearly 100 years. The pizzeria offers a well-rounded menu full of Italian favorites made with fresh ingredients. Try a slice of pizza or opt for a sub, hot sandwich, or stromboli. After a wonderful meal, be sure to try Carmelo’s desserts and famous coffee.
If you’re looking for other things to do near St. Augustine and are craving pizza, Carmelo’s also fulfills to-go orders and offers delivery service. Pick up your take-out order before heading out to see some of the area’s fascinating historical sites or gorgeous natural attractions. You could even have pizza delivered to your St. Augustine beachfront suite!
Borrillo’s Pizza
If New York style pizza is your jam, Borrillo’s Pizza is the place to go. Located within the historic district, this pizzeria is famous for its brick-oven pizzas. The chef at this pizza joint is from Brooklyn, so you can count on an authentic pizza pie.
Gluten-free patrons can also indulge in pizza by trying a cauliflower-crust. Or, try some of Borrillo’s Pizza’s other favorites including lasagna, chicken parmigiana, hot and cold subs, salads, and more!
Borrillo’s is a happening place in the evenings with their live music events. Check the calendar to sing your heart out on karaoke night or hear a great local band. If you enjoy dining al fresco, Borrillo’s offers a lovely outdoor dining space your whole crew will love.
St. Augie’s
Located on the south end of the historic district, St. Augie’s is a favorite with locals. Also specializing in New York style pizza, this pizzeria is known for doing take-out and delivery orders. So, relax in your St. Augustine suite rentals and order in for an easy evening meal! In addition to great pizza, St. Augie’s also offers salads, subs, pasta, wings, and more.
The foosball table at his pizzeria makes St. Augie’s a popular choice for families. With this fun game available, the adults can eat and chat while the kids play. While you’re in the downtown area, you can also see nearby sights such as the Crisp-Ellert Art Museum and the Lightner Museum.
Pizzalley’s
With two locations, Pizzalley’s is known for its quaint dining spaces and tasty pies. Both restaurants are located near the Bridge of Lions. That means this St. Augustine pizza place is a great option for those exploring the historic downtown area. Before lunching at Pizzalley’s, stop by the Fountain of Youth or pop into a museum.
Recently, this local restaurant’s Chianti Room location received a National Award of Excellence from the American Culinary Federation. From marsala to manicotti and build-your-own pizza and pasta, there’s something on the menu for everyone.
Need something family-friendly? Pizzalley’s has you covered with a kid’s menu. If you’re still hungry, you can also enjoy a dessert such as tiramisu or creme brulee.
Vinney’s Pizza
If you’re headed out to Vilano Beach and need pizza near St Augustine, Vinney’s Pizza is the place to stop. Known for their hearty 18 and 20 inch pizza pies, Vinney’s can serve larger groups easily.
Or, if you’re planning on a day out at the beach, pick up some subs on your way for a picnic meal. Other tasty menu items include wraps, jalapeno poppers, wings, and pepperoni pinwheels.
Vinney’s Pizza is a family-owned-and-operated restaurant. It’s open late, serving customers until 10 p.m. on weeknights and 11 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays. That means you can still satisfy your late evening pizza cravings by stopping by or calling in a take-out order. Vinney’s is also famous for their low-priced lunch specials that include two slices of pizza and a drink. Now that’s a meal everyone can enjoy!
Plan Your Visit
Browse our full rental catalog to find the perfect property for your group. Contact the team at Beacher’s Lodge to book your next St. Augustine beach getaway!
900 Pizza & Pasta
This small but mighty St. Augustine restaurant is located on the north side of town. But don’t worry! If you aren’t close by, you can order delivery and eat your pizza at your St. Augustine rentals. Or, you can stop by on your way to or from the Stokes Landing Conservation Area and other nearby attractions.
The most popular items at 900 Pizza & Pasta are wings, white pizza, classic cheese pizza, and fettuccine carbonara. If you’re looking for something unique and different, this pizzeria delivers. With house specials such as Piggy Pizza featuring hickory BBQ sauce, ham, bacon, pulled pork, and more! Or, opt for a vegetable delight with the Ratatouille Pizza. This unique pizza tops your pie with zucchini, eggplant, and other veggies. That’s an out-of-the-ordinary pizza you’ll want to try!
Five Star Pizza
Five Star Pizza is a popular pizza chain in Florida and with good reason. This restaurant is known for its tasty pizza pies made with Wisconsin cheese. At Five Star Pizza, you can find large 18 and 24 inch pizzas to feed your whole crew.
Plus, pick up other favorite menu items like wings and chicken bites. Don’t forget to treat your group with tasty sweets like cinnamon rolls and fudge brownies. There’s something for eveyrone at Fives Star Pizza.
It’s important to note that this pizza joint only offers counter service. So, call ahead to order by phone for pick-up or request delivery service to your St. Augustine balcony suites. Don’t forget to check online for special offers and coupons to get a great deal on your pizza meal.
Stay with Beacher’s Lodge
Now that you know where to get the best pizza in St. Augustine, discover the best St. Augustine rentals to make your stay spectacular. Our St. Augustine rental options include condos, balcony and beachfront suits, and even pet-friendly options.
No matter how many people and furry friends are in your group, we can accommodate your needs. With access to the beach and a gorgeous oceanfront pool, our St. Augustine rentals are a great choice for families and couples.
Beacher’s Lodge is a great home base for a beach vacation. When you stay with us, you get the best of both worlds. You can visit the charming historic center of nearby St. Augustine and the excellent pizzerias there, yet also delight in a secluded home base with ocean views.
Don’t forget there are also historic lighthouses, museums, trolly tours, and the nearby Anastasia State Park to discover! You’ll love having the days to explore before returning to your quiet, spacious St. Augustine rental. We look forward to helping you plan your upcoming vacation!