Your Dinner Guide To Historic St. Augustine Restaurants

St. Augustine, Florida, is a city rich in both history and dining options. In this blog post, we will take you on a culinary journey through some of this charming city’s most iconic and mouthwatering restaurants. From Spanish-Cuban cuisine to fresh seafood delights, St. Augustine has something to satisfy every palate. Our collection of St. Augustine vacation rentals offers you the opportunity to be mere minutes from these fine establishments.

Whether you’re a local or visiting on vacation, let’s dive into the world of historic St. Augustine restaurants. Perfect for your next stay in one of our St. Augustine Rentals!

Columbia Restaurant

For over a century, the Columbia Restaurant has been a staple in St. Augustine. Founded by Spanish-Cuban immigrant Casimiro Hernandez, Sr., the Columbia has grown from a small saloon to the largest Spanish restaurant in the world. With seven locations in Florida, the Columbia is a testament to Casimiro’s American dream. When dining at the Columbia, start your meal with the Columbia’s Original “1905” Salad. This legendary salad is tossed tableside and features crisp iceberg lettuce, julienne of baked ham, Swiss cheese, tomato, olives, grated Romano cheese, Worcestershire sauce, and their signature garlic dressing. No wonder it won USA Today’s award for “One of Ten Great Places to Make a Meal Out of a Salad.” If you’re looking for a satisfying main course, indulge in their Original Cuban Sandwich, named the “Best Sandwich in Florida” by Food & Wine Magazine. This mouthwatering creation includes mojo-marinated roast pork, ham, Genoa salami, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard. Complement your meal with one of their exclusive fine wines, and you’re in for a dining experience fit for the perfect St. Augustine vacation.

Catch 27

Based in the heart of historic St. Augustine, Catch 27 is passionate about serving fresh, locally caught seafood. They believe in preparing everything from scratch, using seasonal ingredients and local produce. When you visit Catch 27, you’re in for a truly authentic dining experience. Start your meal by indulging in their Smoked Salmon Spread, served with toasted pita and dill pickle tartar sauce. This appetizer perfectly showcases their commitment to taste and quality. Try their enticing Blackened Pasta, made with orzo pasta, cherry tomatoes, Tuscan kale, and parmesan in a kale pesto cream sauce for your main course. And don’t forget to choose your favorite protein—chicken, shrimp, fish, or salmon—to accompany this delectable dish. To elevate your dining experience, pair your meal with a glass of rich red wine or a crisp white wine. Whether you’re a seasoned seafood enthusiast or a landlubber curious to explore the flavors of the sea, Catch 27 has something for everyone.

Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grill

Founded by Louis and Greg Saig, Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grill brings the vibrant flavors of Louisiana to historic St. Augustine. What started as a small establishment with limited menu options has evolved into a favorite dining spot with a rich culinary heritage. Begin your dinner at Harry’s with their Signature Crab Cakes, pan-seared to perfection and served with roasted red pepper aioli. This dish offers a decadent start to any meal, showcasing the bold flavors that define Harry’s menu. If you’re craving fresh seafood, look no further than Harry’s Mahi-Mahi. Straight from the North Atlantic, this delectable fish is served alongside Nola rice and fresh veggies, accompanied by a light lemon cream sauce. As you indulge in the flavors of Harry’s, don’t forget to explore their signature cocktail menu. The Big Easy, made with Captain Morgan Original Spiced Rum, Southern Comfort, amaretto, banana liqueur, Midori, pineapple, and sour, is just one example of the creative libations they offer.

St. Augustine Fish Camp

Ben and Liza Groshell opened St. Augustine Fish Camp in 2020, inspired by their vision of creating a restaurant with a neighborhood feel and serving the freshest seafood with a creative twist. This venue’s inviting interior mirrors the freshness of the catch of the day, while the shimmering sunlight on the water adds a touch of magic to your dining experience. Known as the local sanctuary for a getaway-like ambiance, St. Augustine Fish Camp offers a menu that celebrates the flavors of the coastal region. To start your meal, indulge in their Fried Green Tomatoes with Herbed Goat Cheese. Made with the freshest ingredients, this dish provides a delightful balance of tanginess and creaminess. For the main course, their Spicy Seafood Linguini is a feast showcasing the local waters’ bounty. Featuring sea scallops, shrimp, calamari, clams, a white wine reduction, garlic, tomato, and pecorino cheese, this pasta dish is a true delicacy. And why not elevate your dining experience with a classic Old Fashioned? Their version, made with bourbon, Luxardo cherries, and fresh orange, adds a touch of luxury to your meal.

Stay With Beacher’s Lodge Oceanfront Suites

Look no further than Beacher’s Lodge Oceanfront Suites for a comfortable and convenient retreat. At Beacher’s Lodge, you’ll find an excellent selection of St. Augustine vacation condo rentals. Our oceanfront suites provide a relaxing atmosphere, allowing you to unwind while enjoying breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean from your balcony or patio. The suites are equipped with kitchenettes, giving you the freedom to prepare your own meals and make the most of your St. Augustine vacation. Take advantage of the outdoor pool during your stay, which offers a refreshing escape from the warm Florida sun. Beacher’s Lodge’s convenient location also makes it easy to explore nearby attractions and activities, such as St. Augustine’s historic downtown, the Castillo de San Marcos National Monument, and the St. Augustine Lighthouse. Whether you’re planning a short getaway or an extended vacation, Beacher’s Lodge Oceanfront Suites offers the perfect blend of comfort and convenience. Book your stay today and experience the beauty of St. Augustine firsthand.